View Profile
Best Personal Trainers near Bay Shore, NY
3 of these trainers are based in Bay Shore; the others serve Bay Shore from towns including West Babylon (6 mi), Smithtown (9 mi) and Farmingdale (10 mi).
3 open 24/7 · all 24 open weekends · 21 rated 4.5+
Data verified October 21, 2026
View Profile
Stay Fit Culture
- Motivated
“The Elite Training squad amiably known as the Guru, Dunderty, the Assassin and the Grim Reaper are going to push you not just physically but mentally.”
View Profile
I.e. Personal Training Inc
View Profile
Namaste the Yoga Spa
- Mind
- Hot Yoga
“It was my first time ever doing hot yoga or even going to a studio in a long time and the entire experience from start to finish was amazing.”
View Profile
Huners Fitness Advantage
- Attention
- Space
- Needs
“I'd highly recommend Huner's Fitness Advantage to anyone who is serious about being the best you can be from a fitness and nutritional perspective.”
View Profile
Gymguyz Long Island
- Results
- Motivated
- Plan
“My children and I have been working with Joe Piscopia for over a year and we couldn't be more pleased by the tremendous results in our strength, agility and overall physical fitness.”
This page lists 24 personal trainers and training gyms recorded for Bay Shore, NY. What each one says about its approach, its hours and its booking comes from its own website; ratings and quotes come from public reviews.
Area overview: Bay Shore, NY
23 of the 24 trainers on this page have a rating, from 3.7 to 5.0 across 1,883 reviews; 17 have 50 or more reviews and 21 are rated 4.5 or higher. When students and parents rate these trainers on specific qualities, they most often praise professionalism (98%), quality (86%) and communication (83%). The topics that come up most in reviews of the trainers on this page are "equipment", "community" and "motivating". 3 are open around the clock; 22 are open on Saturdays and 17 on Sundays. 1 lists staff certifications (ACSM) and 1 has a BBB rating of A or A+. Domain records put 12 websites of the trainers on this page at ten or more years old; the oldest dates from 2005. 1 offers a free trial or consultation; 3 are family- or locally-owned and 3 list coupons or special offers. We have a website on file for all 24 of the trainers on this page; 18 publish a contact page; 17 list a public email and 5 take bookings online. We count these figures across the trainers on this page; distances are straight-line, and hours and prices change, so confirm the details with the trainer before you enroll.
Why are some trainers here not in Bay Shore?
3 of the 24 listings are based in Bay Shore. The rest come from other towns within 20 mi. Distances are straight-line, and plenty of trainers take clients from further out than their address suggests.
View Profile
Transfitnation
- Plan
- Shape
- Health
“I found transfitnation because my son it's in the autism spectrum and if it could help any parents looking for a place to take their son / daughter to keep their health goals this is the place.”
View Profile
Outlift Athletics
- Trainers
- Machines
- Motivated
“Mike and Alisa, along with the rest of the staff at Outlift have been nothing but welcoming, supportive, motivated to their customers who step foot into their facility.”
View Profile
Loco Motion New York
“Thanks to their coaching, support, and motivation, I continue to achieve movements and routines once thought too challenging to accomplish (ring routines, 5 rep strict ring muscle up, shoulder stands, etc).”
View Profile
Mind Body Fit
- Pain
- Injuries
- Plan
“Mike Di Sapio works to find the perfect nutritional and physical routine for each of his clients exclusively so that you stick with it with optimal results.”
View Profile
Farmingdale Xpress Body Boot Camp
- Health
- Team
- Weight Loss
“I went in knowing I needed to put the work and effort in and was greeted by Manny and his team (Rich and Jesse) and they have pushed me to where I needed to be!”
View Profile
Cow Harbor Crossfit
- Motivate
- Athletes
- Goals
“Never did any sort of classes when it came to training so was a bit skeptical, but everyone there is extremely welcoming and encourages you to succeed.”
View Profile
Forever Fit Method
“The knowledgeable training staff has helped me progress my goals far exceeding the results I've been able to achieve both on my own and from similar gyms in the area.”
View Profile
Gaglione Strength
- Distance
- Squat
- Matter
“Yesterday, I attended the Squats for America, and I saw families competing together, as well as lifters as young as 13 to as old as in their late 70's!!”
View Profile
Simply Fit Personal Training
- Cardio
- Trainers
“I have been trying to work out in the am for 15 years with 0 success, but once I signed up and started going at 6am on Tue and Thu I have yet to cancel once.”
View Profile
Mike Lynch
“Between his nutrition expertise to his incredibly effective workouts, he has gotten my body to transform and change in ways I've never been able to achieve before on my own.”
View Profile
Xtreme Fitness LI
“He's been very attentive to my goals and help me construct a plan to achieve it and more importantly helped me find and maintain the motivation to get it.”
View Profile
Stoked Athletics
“When I first started at Stoked it was initially though contest they had of giving away a free month at the gym, but as I spent the time there, I grew to find it to be like a second home.”
View Profile
The Trainer Page
- Energy
- Mentally
- Sweat
“It's a good tool if you are looking to make a significant change in your appearance but, isn't necessary for someone who is looking for just a high burning workout session”
View Profile
Prevention + Performance
“I went there having suffered 10 knee surgeries on my right knee and finally had a replacement (I'm only 43) and this place got me back to a much higher functioning level.”
View Profile
Ash Hot Yoga
- Community
- Room
- Energy
“This was one of the first times I did a hot 26 that had an instructor who cracked jokes and was lighthearted during the class and it 100% enhanced the experience.”
View Profile
Unique Fitness
- Locker Room
- Sauna
- Atmosphere
“This gym is amazing, they have top equipment, a great environment and are very motivating if you're looking for something to bring you to the next level.”
View Profile
Elevation Fitness
- Selection
- Plan
- Personal Training
“Lastly and just as important, the gym is Always clean due to a wonderful Cleaning Service that come in weekly, and they are always pleasant and friendly Thanks Pete for creating such a great gym!”
View Profile
Crossfit South Shore
- Strength
- Athlete
- Matter
“I'm returning to Cross Fit after being diagnosed with Chron's disease and this gym is the perfect environment for a healthy and smart approach to a comeback.”
Why these companies made our list
What students and parents say about trainers near Bay Shore
- “The personal trainers at Forever Fit Method are professional, motivating, friendly and knowledgeable.” — from a review of Forever Fit Method
- “If you are looking for a knowledgeable, motivating, and supportive personal trainers to guide you on your fitness journey, I wholeheartedly recommend Transfitnation.” — from a review of Transfitnation
- “I surpassed all of my fitness goals with his guidance on nutrition and a workout plan.” — from a review of Mike Lynch
- “I highly recommend Transfitnation to anyone looking to get in shape with this group of knowledgeable personal trainers.” — from a review of Transfitnation
Excerpts from public reviews of the trainers listed on this page.
Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
